Fame may not clear a cited mark
Myth: "We are famous, so the earlier mark cited against us will have to step aside."
Fact: reputation alone may not clear a cited mark out of the way. Cancellation of the cited mark may be needed.
There is a second point foreign brand owners should keep in mind. When a case turns on priority, old evidence of use and registration is what counts. An owner unable to prove rights before the cited mark's date can lose on the experts' report.
In practice
- 01
Do not rely on reputation by itself
- 02
Ask early whether cancellation of the cited mark may be needed
- 03
Collect old evidence of use and registration
- 04
Check what you can prove from before the cited mark's date
Priority cases turn on old evidence
Two brands, one question: who came first?
Suppose a dispute turns on priority. The court experts review the official files, check registrations at home and abroad to see who used the mark first, and look at import evidence.
In that situation, old evidence of use and registration is what counts. An owner unable to prove rights before the cited mark's date can lose on the experts' report.
For a foreign brand owner, the lesson is simple: the evidence that matters is the old evidence.
Key points
- 01
Locate old evidence of use
- 02
Locate old registrations, at home and abroad
- 03
Check what you can prove from before the cited mark's date
- 04
Keep your import evidence together